House Republicans & Democrats vote to strip anti-trust exemption for health insurance industry

Three Republicans side with Democrats in the House Judiciary committee to strip the health insurance industry of McCarran Act exemptions.

Industry spokeswoman Karen Ignagni immediately threatens retaliation against consumers.

Washington Post, October 21st, 2009

The House Judiciary Committee voted Wednesday to strip federal antitrust protections shielding health insurers from investigations into price fixing and other business practices, the first step in a legislative bid to clamp down on the much-maligned industry.

Although Democrats have led the repeal push in recent weeks, the committee’s 20-9 vote came with the support of three Republicans. The legislation would repeal portions of the 1945 McCarran-Ferguson Act that allows states to regulate health insurance providers without federal intervention. But critics of the law say that 64 years after its passage, the result has been regional monopolies that inflate premiums and discriminate against people based on their health status, gender and other factors. More…

In our view, both insurance & banking should lose their McCarran Act exemptions. Anti-competitive, anti-consumer practices are widespread in predatory lending, automobile & life insurance, homeowner’s insurance (Katrina!) and credit card practices.
Email This Post Email This Post

Leave a Reply

Creative Slice, Green website design from Tucson, AZ